The promise of a four hour workweek magically righting all wrongs in your life, is a lie. Not only is it highly implausible, but if you ever do achieve a four hour work week, you’ll probably want to get rid of it.
Why is the Four Hour Workweek (4HWW for short) a lie? Well, there’s two reasons. Number one, it’s come to the attention of quite a few people that Tim Ferriss really defines “work” as something you don’t want to do. Mandatory, unpleasant, tedious, repetitive tasks that you’d rather defer or delegate to someone else. This is quite a narrow definition of work. I would be more inclined to say Tim’s definition of work is more synonymous with a chore.
So that’s the first reason. The second reason is this… The definition most people have of work is totally disempowering. It’s more in line with slavery, toiling and punishment. Work is seen as something you have to do to pay your dues. How many times did you hear your mom or dad say as a kid “I worked hard to buy/make/microwave this food and you better eat it!” We’re brought up with our parents making us think that work is some kind of grueling sacrifice they’ve done to “give us a better life.” (The intended message may have been to instill respect for hard work, but usually the outcome is feeling guilty for being born.)
Since work is seen as such a must — something we must do to pay the bills and to survive — we don’t realize that it’s not required that we see work as something other than a chore. Just because we’re born with a bad definition of something doesn’t mean we have to keep it. Work is more than just a chore, at least to me.
Work is sacred.
Work is giving yourself. It’s creative self-expression. It’s opening your heart and providing value to others. It’s exchanging a part of yourself with someone else. It’s a possibility for you to make a difference in the world.
Seeing work as just something to do to get by is like slapping yourself in the face.
Here’s why I just can’t slap myself anymore:
- I don’t want to spend one third of my life living out of a sense of drudgery.
- I don’t want to rent out my body and mind for five of seven days of the week.
- I don’t want to spend every day counting down the minutes to lunch, then counting again to five o’clock.
- But much, much, much more than that, I don’t want to confine myself to choosing work that isn’t meaningful and doesn’t matter to me.
And that’s really the biggest problem with seeing work as menial labor. By defining work as such, you incarcerate yourself in a narrow field of possibilities of what work could be. Yes, work can be tedious. Doing your taxes, filing receipts, stapling, responding to email, and doing repetitive tasks can be pretty damn boring. There’s no way to trick yourself into believing otherwise. (Non-resistance to the tedium, however, can make it a lot less painful.) But despite the tedium, work can be much more than that. The work you do can be the gift of what you leave behind on this earth when you’re gone. It can be the difference you make in other peoples lives.
Something different.
When you expand your definition of what work is to a mutually beneficial exchange of value, it becomes more of a blessing and an opportunity.
This is the way I’ve started to think about work; I ask myself, “With the work you do today, how can you create the biggest positive impact in other people’s lives, while fulfilling your own dreams at the same time?”
And if I have work to do that is truly boring (like figuring out how much taxes I owe) I ask myself, “I know this work isn’t what I’d absolutely love to do, but since it must be done, by not resisting it, can I make it less painful?”
I also have to be careful to distinguish between work that must be done (like taxes) and things that seem required, but really aren’t. For example, it might be a good idea for me to spend some time every day networking, but if it doesn’t feel authentic, it would be a waste of time. If I really felt like creating, rather than connecting, I should honor that feeling. When I express myself authentically, I naturally have a greater impact then when I force myself to do something because I think it would be a good idea.
When you start to see work as play, as giving yourself to the world, as being an agent of change, you completely shatter the perception of work as a burden.
Because that’s where all this seeking to escape from work comes from (which is really what the 4HWW is about). Whether it be counting down the days to your yearly two week vacation, setting up a four hour workweek or creating passive income; whether it be the desire to retire early, win the lottery or strike it rich, it’s all in the effort to escape from the obligation of spending your life in a state of endless resistance to doing chores. It’s like we’re six years old again, fighting with mom about cleaning up all the stuff we’ve crammed under our bed. Not much has changed, huh?
But when work becomes something reverent to you, you no longer to seek escape from it. Besides, imagine if you really did find that elusive escape. Would it really solve all your problems? Sure, you’d have a lot of free time, but is that really what you’re looking for? Just free time?
I think it’s something more than that. I think it’s the lack of purpose, the lack of depth in our work that leads us to chase ideas like a four hour workweek and autopilot income.
Guess what?
No amount of freedom of time will quench your desire to make a difference, to live with purpose.
As Rolf Potts represents in his awesome book, Vagabonding, you can only live so long sipping martinis on a beach. Sooner or later, you’ll be bored. You’ll want to actually do something that matters.
Despite all the head-drilling society does to make you think work equates slavery, there are many possibilities for work to be a joy.
One of those options is The Zero Hour Workweek — a guide to getting paid to be who you are.
(Note: I did learn a lot from The Four Hour Workweek. I think Tim has some great ideas, like mini retirements, following a low information diet, etc. I also think he did an awesome job pointing out the stupidity of “work for work’s sake.” However, I do think the central idea of the achievement of a four hour workweek solving all of your problems is misleading. Tim defines work as something you really despise, and I just think that’s confusing things more, rather than bringing clarity to the situation. I guess it’s all about semantics, though, right? As Clinton said during the Monica Lewinski case, “Please define sexual relations.”)
[...] Jonathon Nasman’s blog post earlier this week called The Lie of the Four Hour Work Week in which he challenges our ideas about work. It’s worth your time to read [...]
[...] Meade has posted an article titled The Lie of The Four Hour Work Week. A compelling [...]
[...] wrote a great post called “The Lie of The Four Hour Work Week.” It’s a brief review of the actual book, but, more importantly, it talks about Tim [...]
[...] was reading an article on one of my favorite, though rarely updated (kinda like my site), blogs today about how The 4 Hour [...]
[...] The Four Hour Work Week has been sitting on my bookshelf for over a year…unread. Which may be more… The four hour work week is a myth and a lie. Not only is it highly implausible, but if you ever do achieve a four hour work week, you’ll probably want to get rid of it. [...]
[...] to add to the conversation. They deserve serious reflection, such as Jonathan’s post about how we define our relationship to ‘work’. I feel so strongly about this, and am still playing with this idea, that I feel unable to write [...]
[...] Illuminated Mind’s The Lie of the Four Hour Work Week [...]
[...] to turn around and show others how to follow their own path. This conversation has spanned from Jonathan Mead, the brilliant people on the Beyond Productivity calls, Naomi Dunford, Mark Silver, Steve Spalding, [...]
[...] those same posts never go into enough detail, enough information for me. It always feels like there’s so [...]
[...] arguament?). But now it looks like it is the turn of The Four Hour Work Week. Jonathan Mead has a very detailed critique, saying that the promise of a four hour work week magically righting all the wrongs in your life is [...]
[...] doesn’t have to be so painful that we can’t wait to escape it. Jonathon Mead suggests if we choose meaningful work it becomes a “mutually beneficial exchange of value…more of a blessing and an opportunity.” [...]
[...] getting more productive as a creative person. One of the articles that grabbed my attention was Illuminated mind: The Lie of the Four Hour Work Week in which the Four Hour Work Week by Tim Ferris was discussed. I admire what Tim Ferris is doing and [...]
[...] Mead called the promise of a 4-hour work week a lie. Penelope Trunk said the week Tim Ferriss actually works a 4-hour work week will be a cold week in [...]
[...] passion and the ability to choose to work on or for something they are passionate about sometimes confuses passion with enjoyment. Passion leads you to work towards something. And sometimes the work on the path towards that [...]
[...] Society typically defines “work” as the stuff you don’t want to do, but have to do. Most people don’t know why this is the way it is, and they don’t take the initiative to question that assumption, so they accept that work is supposed to be a chore. But Jonathan recognized at an early age (like I did, like you did) that work and play shouldn’t have to be mutually exclusive. “For a long time I didn’t know it was possible to stop participating. I didn’t realize that I could choose that, or something different. That was until I started testing this convention: the cultural consensus that work must not be fun.“ [...]
[...] the terminology and offered several techniques for designing the lifestyle of your choice. Though some have bashed the idea of a 4-hour work week, many other books, blogs, and websites have since popped up [...]
[...] URL : http://www.illuminatedmind.net/2009/03/17/the-lie-of-the-four-hour-work-week/ [...]
[...] Mead wrote an article on his Illuminated Mind blog called the Lie of the Four Hour Work Week. I rather enjoyed it. He underscored in that blog some of the objections to the 4HWW that were [...]
[...] from my favorite blogs, I notice a few common elements. I repeatedly see these elements: passion, controversy, saying something that everyone is thinking but afraid to say, taking an opposite stance on a [...]
[...] The 4 Hour Work Week did raise some interesting points for me. Over at Illuminated Mind’s “The Lie of The Four Hour Work Week.”, the book is dissected to another level. It’s full of good points if you’ve read the [...]
[...] weekend I read this article – The Lie of the 4 Hour Work Week. I really enjoyed it, and it shed light on some [...]
[...] Bestselling Four-Hour Workweek might have a misleading title (as Jonathan Mead @Illuminated Mind points out), but Tim’s passion for testing and experimentation result in some of the most remarkable [...]
[...] It’s a book on how to escape from work and instead do the things you enjoy. The thing is, as Jonathan Mead points out, it assumes that you don’t enjoy your work. That’s a real pity. Instead of outsourcing [...]
[...] and so is working your arse off to achieve what you want in life. This is not always a bad thing. Jonathan Mead makes the excellent point that, ‘as Rolf Potts represents in his awesome book, Vagabonding, you [...]